During negotiation of an off-plan purchase, the developer generally requires the buyer to sign a reservation form and a final purchase contract.
This contract is the legal instrument that defines the legal obligations of each of the Parties. However, as the balance of power between them is often unequal, abusive clauses are frequently introduced into the contract.
What is the legal validity of these clauses?
The Attorney General of Israel took the initiative of turning to the Israeli courts to rule definitively on the legal validity of recurring clauses written into purchase contracts for off-plan properties whose content was clearly to the buyer’s disadvantage.
Analysis of the validity of some recurring abusive clauses written into purchase contracts for off-plan properties.
Clause 1 – Reduction of the developer’s liability if the specification document is changed.
Content of the clause: “The developer will be responsible for repairing at its own expense any malfunction resulting from work carried out by it, in accordance with the specification document annexed to the contract. However, if the buyer wishes to change the specification document or replace one of the materials with another, the developer declines all liability for the quality, colour, matching, delivery or installation of these.”
The developer’s arguments: The developer is committed only to the quality of the materials and products supplied by it. By ordering products different from those in the specification document, the buyer releases the developer from all liability and must turn exclusively to the supplier they chose in the event of any malfunction or problem.
Court decision: This clause is abusive since the developer does not allow the buyer to use the supplier of their choice, but only one of those with whom it usually works.
This unilateral constraint imposed on the buyer primarily benefits the developer and allows it to generate financial gains.
The developer therefore also bears a share of responsibility for the quality of the service provided and, in the event of a malfunction, the buyer may turn either to the supplier or to the developer.
Clause 2 – Cancellation of the buyer’s right of refund or deduction.
Content of the clause: “The buyer will not be allowed to deduct any sum from the purchase price, for any reason.”
Court decision: This clause is abusive since it contradicts Section 53 of the Israeli Contracts Law, which provides that the Parties are entitled to deduct the sums corresponding to their mutual obligations.
In addition, the Court held that this clause was unnecessary to protect the developer’s interests, since the handover of the keys of a new apartment is conditional on payment of the full purchase price to the developer.
Clause 3 – Requirement of writing for any change.
Content of the clause: “Any change to the contract or its annexes by either Party must be made in writing. Any change not made in writing will not be taken into account.”
The Attorney General’s arguments: The invalidity of any change not notified in writing risks misleading the buyer, who could no longer rely on a possible verbal agreement made with the developer.
The Attorney General therefore suggested that any agreement customarily concluded orally be made valid.
The developer’s arguments: The developer argued that the obligation to make changes in writing served the interests of both Parties and would avoid any misunderstanding between them.
Court decision: The court, taking a position going beyond the Attorney General’s proposal, held that this clause was abusive towards the buyer and had to be cancelled.
Rimon Nadlan, real estate agency in Ra’anana headed by Karine Ayache, specialises in the purchase of apartments, rentals, new projects and Tama 38 projects.
It welcomes dozens of new immigrants every year from France and elsewhere.
Thanks to Credit Immobilier en Israel, whom we recommend as a financial partner for all your projects.
Please note: The information contained in this article is the sole responsibility of the author and cannot replace specific legal advice. It is valid only as of the date it was written.
Maître Yonathan TSADIKA
+ 972 (0) 50 486 34 76
yonathan@tsadika.co.il

