Negotiations generally start a few weeks before the signing of the final purchase contract.
During this period, the Parties agree on the legal terms and commercial conditions of the contract, carry out all the customary checks and put together the financing.
If one of the Parties decides to withdraw without valid reason, it is exposed to legal proceedings.
In which cases are the Parties legally free to withdraw from a negotiation? What are the consequences if one of the Parties withdraws without valid reasons?
One of the fundamental principles of negotiations between future Parties is the obligation of transparency and good faith that rests on them.
Even though the contract has not been signed, Section 12 of the Israeli Contracts Law, passed in 1973, requires the Parties to behave fairly and honestly.
This requirement also includes taking into account the interests and constraints of the other Party, as well as full cooperation with it.
Besides the obligation of transparency under the Contracts Law, the seller is also subject to Section 16 of the law on real estate transactions, which requires the seller to disclose to the buyer the facts known to them that may not match the buyer’s expectations.
In addition, case law has held that the duty of transparency incumbent on the Parties must be actively applied: the Parties exchange the information in their possession about the transaction under way and behave like co-signatories of a contract.
For example, a seller whose lawyer is negotiating with a potential buyer is not allowed to continue showing their apartment or to conduct parallel negotiations with a third party.
Conversely, the buyer of a property who is in the middle of negotiations cannot continue to visit other apartments and back out if they find one of them more attractive.
Moreover, Israeli case law specifies that the seriousness of a breach of the duty of good faith during negotiations is proportional to how far the negotiations have advanced.
This assessment is made case by case, according to the stage the negotiations had reached and the specific circumstances that led to the situation.
When negotiations are at an advanced stage, abandoning them must be justified by a plausible and credible reason.
In which cases can the agreement be considered concluded?
The law on real estate transactions requires the contract to be in writing.
In addition, case law requires that the basic information be stated in it, namely: the price, the names of the Parties, the description of the property and the purpose of the transaction.
Therefore, once these points have been agreed between the Parties, and all the more so if this was done in writing (signing of a promise to sell or exchange of drafts between the lawyers), an agreement may be considered to exist. In that case, the court will tend to consider the contract valid and to sanction a Party that withdraws.
Moreover, if the court considers that the conduct of the Parties should prevail over the requirement for a written purchase contract, this may be interpreted as the conclusion of an agreement.
For example, the Judge may consider that two individuals who agreed on the terms of the transaction and shook hands have concluded an agreement, even though no document was signed between them.
What are the risks?
In the event of breach of the obligations of good faith and transparency prior to the signing of a contract, the injured Party is entitled to file a complaint with the court to claim compensation for the damage caused to it.
It may also ask the court to issue a temporary injunction intended, among other things, to freeze any transaction relating to the property.
Rimon Nadlan, real estate agency in Ra’anana headed by Karine Ayache, specialises in the purchase of apartments, rentals, new projects and Tama 38 projects.
It welcomes dozens of new immigrants every year from France and elsewhere.
Thanks to Credit Immobilier en Israel, whom we recommend as a financial partner for all your projects.
Please note: The information contained in this article is the sole responsibility of the author and cannot replace specific legal advice. It is valid only as of the date it was written.
Maître Yonathan TSADIKA
+ 972 (0) 50 486 34 76
yonathan@tsadika.co.il

